Judges Analysis in Case Laws

Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font

Judges in a case law are considered as a data point for various case law research courses on lawhub.in.  We all are well aware of that judges the highest authority in the court room are  impartial, and work more on facts and the arguments conducted by the advocates in court. However, the law is all about interpretation and as not everyone is the same it is inevitable that one judge may interpret something different from another.

Before working or conducting an analysis on any judge, first and foremost is to collect the case laws involving the judge for the analysis. Generating a patters realted with judges is the prime objective of the research analysis. Relating the judges data points with other fixed and variable data points for an assertive analysis should always be the prime goa set by the research student. The pattern generation always helps in the predecitive analysis or the out come of the cases related with a specific judges. Through the correct analysis of legal documents, it is possible to identify hidden patterns that would not have otherwise be visible.

While considering the judges analysi the quantitative and qualitatibe analytics can have a double impact on the research. This method of analytics can provide valuable insight into how to craft legal arguments in a way that might be better received by one judge over another. Predictive analytic techniques can be deployed here to aid with specific phrasing and can even highlight relevant arguments that have previously resonated well with that judge in similar cases previously. Over time it is likely that as more law firms gain access to this type of awareness it will put pressure on judges to be more consistent in their rulings. This in turn will both strengthen this type of system but also mean that incorrect rulings will become less frequent.

Futrther more the bench also considered while analysis a judge. Judgment bench is decided based on the number of judges involved in reciting a case law and the conclusion.

Following are the type of bench for a relevant judgement. Many times the case and it impotance also decides the Bench. Based on the bench the judgments importance also can be decided. This can a topic of research included while doing a research on the judges and can be related with the bench.

Following are the various type of Bench assocated with the judgement.

  1. Name of One judge- Single Bench
  2. Name of Two Judges- Division Bench
  3. Name of Three or more Judges- Full Bench
  4. Constitution Bench- Constitution Bench


“Highlight relevant arguments that have previously resonated well with that judge.”